SavitriStudy wiki

The Triple Soul-Forces

Book 7, Canto 4. On the narrow pilgrim path where The Entry into the Inner Countries left her, Savitri meets three figures in succession. Each is a Madonna — a great feminine power. Each declares the same astonishing sentence: I am thy secret soul. Each is answered, in her turn, by a "warped echo" from below — the human voice corresponding to her in the ordinary world, distorted by ignorance. The first Madonna is Suffering (the Mother of the seven sorrows); her echo is the tortured Man of Sorrows, the Titan in rebellious despair. The second is Might (Durga / Lakshmi / Kali); her echo is the conquering technological Ego who would seize God's powers for himself. The third is Light (peace and grace); her echo is the sense-shackled scientific mind that maps everything and believes nothing.

Savitri answers each Madonna with the same recognition — thou art a portion of my soul put forth — and the same verdict: she is real, she is necessary, but she is not enough. Each is sent back with a promise: One day I will return. The canto's central revelation is that the divine soul Savitri seeks is not one of the three. They are aspects of it, projected outward into the world's struggle. She must go further to find the Self of which they are partial expressions. That finding is The Finding of the Soul|the next canto.

What the canto is doing

It is doing three things together. First, it is cataloguing the forms in which the Divine Mother is already at work in humanity — compassion, force, light — and giving each its mythological lineage (Mater Dolorosa, Durga-Kali-Lakshmi, the Mother of Grace). Second, it is naming the human distortion that corresponds to each — the cult of suffering and the Titan's rebellion against it, the cult of force and the Promethean conquest of nature, the cult of reason and the scientific agnosticism that refuses transcendence. Third, it is setting the standard for the rest of Book 7: Savitri's soul is not these powers, however necessary they are; the soul is what stands behind all three and could send all three out as its portions.

The canto also restates and extends what Sri Aurobindo wrote elsewhere in The Mother, where four aspects of the Mother are named — Maheshwari (wisdom), Mahakali (force), Mahalakshmi (harmony / love), Mahasaraswati (perfection / detail-work). Here the schema is condensed into three. The choice is dramatic: each of the three is given speech, given an echo, and given Savitri's response.

The structural pattern

The canto is built as three movements with identical architecture:

  1. A description of the Madonna's seat and figure.
  2. The Madonna's speech beginning O Savitri, I am thy secret soul.
  3. A warped echo from "below" — the corresponding human voice.
  4. Savitri's reply, beginning Madonna of [suffering / might / light], thou art a portion of my soul put forth.
  5. A promise: One day I will return.

The repetition is the point. Each Madonna says she is the soul. Each is told she is only a portion of it. The pattern is the canto's argument.

First — the Madonna of Suffering

The first figure appears on barren ground:

A moon-bright face in a sombre cloud of hair, A Woman sat in a pale lustrous robe. A rugged and ragged soil was her bare seat, Beneath her feet a sharp and wounding stone.

She is the Mater Dolorosa — the Mother of the seven sorrows bore / The seven stabs that pierced her bleeding heart. Sri Aurobindo gives her the universe as her body of woe:

"O Savitri, I am thy secret soul. To share the suffering of the world I came, I draw my children's pangs into my breast. I am the nurse of the dolour beneath the stars; I am the soul of all who wailing writhe Under the ruthless harrow of the Gods."

Her self-description runs through the social registry of women's pain:

"I am woman, nurse and slave and beaten beast; I tend the hands that gave me cruel blows. The hearts that spurned my love and zeal I serve…"

And through the catastrophes of history:

"I have seen the peasant burning in his hut, I have seen the slashed corpse of the slaughtered child, Heard woman's cry ravished and stripped and haled Amid the bayings of the hell-hound mob, I have looked on, I had no power to save. I have brought no arm of strength to aid or slay; God gave me love, he gave me not his force."

The line God gave me love, he gave me not his force names her exact limitation. Compassion without power is what she is. She has the universal heart and not the universal arm. Sri Aurobindo lets her speak her dignified hope:

"I am the hope that looks towards my God, My God who never came to me till now; His voice I hear that ever says 'I come': I know that one day he shall come at last."

This is the patience of compassion that has not yet been joined to the Force that can change conditions. The Madonna is not in despair. She is in waiting.

The Titan echo

The echo from below is one of the canto's most uncomfortable passages because it is the speech of the justified sufferer — the human who has taken his suffering as the central fact of his existence and turned it into the basis of a worldview:

"I am the Man of Sorrows, I am he Who is nailed on the wide cross of the universe; To enjoy my agony God built the earth, My passion he has made his drama's theme."

Sri Aurobindo has the figure draw on the Western and Greek archetypes:

"I am Prometheus under the vulture's beak, Man the discoverer of the undying fire, In the flame he kindled burning like a moth; I am the seeker who can never find, I am the fighter who can never win, I am the runner who never touched his goal…"

The speech turns from suffering into the Titan's ethic — the philosophy that suffering produces. Each in himself is sole by Nature's law. Only by force and ruse can man survive. Pity is a weakness in his breast. And it ends in a strange satisfaction:

"There is a dull consent in my sluggish heart, A fierce satisfaction with my special pangs As if they made me taller than my kind; Only by suffering can I excel."

This is Sri Aurobindo's diagnosis of the pathology — the use of pain to certify the self. It is the Madonna of Suffering's voice with the divinity removed. He gave her love without force; her echo has force without love. They are the two halves of one broken thing.

Savitri's answer

Her reply is the canto's first statement of the formula:

"Madonna of suffering, Mother of grief divine, Thou art a portion of my soul put forth To bear the unbearable sorrow of the world. Because thou art, men yield not to their doom, But ask for happiness and strive with fate; Because thou art, the wretched still can hope. But thine is the power to solace, not to save."

The exact verdict: the power to solace, not to save. Compassion is real and necessary; it keeps the world from falling into despair. But it cannot end the conditions that produce sorrow. The promise that follows names what is to come:

"One day I will return, a bringer of strength, And make thee drink from the Eternal's cup… Misery shall pass abolished from the earth; The world shall be freed from the anger of the Beast, From the cruelty of the Titan and his pain."

The pattern set here will hold for each Madonna: what you do is good, what you are is partial, I will bring you what you lack.

Second — the Madonna of Might

The path climbs:

An ardent grandeur climbed mid ferns and rocks… Here on a boulder carved like a huge throne A Woman sat in gold and purple sheen, Armed with the trident and the thunderbolt, Her feet upon a couchant lion's back.

The iconography names her immediately — the lion is Durga's vehicle; the trident and thunderbolt are her weapons. Sri Aurobindo's hymn to her is splendid:

A formidable smile curved round her lips, Heaven-fire laughed in the corners of her eyes… Guarding in the wide cosmic battlefield Against the flat equality of Death And the all-levelling insurgent Night The hierarchy of the ordered Powers, The high changeless values, the peaked eminences, The privileged aristocracy of Truth…

Her speech identifies her with the great Hindu goddesses by name:

"O Savitri, I am thy secret soul. I have come down into the human world… I am Durga, goddess of the proud and strong, And Lakshmi, queen of the fair and fortunate; I wear the face of Kali when I kill, I trample the corpses of the demon hordes."

She names her work — siding with the oppressed, throwing down tyrants, breaking pride, leading men to the divine path:

"I rend man's narrow and successful life And force his sorrowful eyes to gaze at the sun That he may die to earth and live in his soul."

But she names her limit too, in lines that are doctrinally important for the rest of the epic:

"But the great obstinate world resists my Word, And the crookedness and evil in man's heart Is stronger than Reason, profounder than the Pit, And the malignancy of hostile Powers Puts craftily back the clock of destiny And mightier seems than the eternal Will. The cosmic evil is too deep to unroot, The cosmic suffering is too vast to heal. A few I guide who pass me towards the Light; A few I save, the mass falls back unsaved."

This is the Mother of Force as she currently is in the world — a power that wins individual battles but cannot yet uproot the conditions. Her faith is steady — Slowly the light grows greater in the East — but it is the faith of slow progress, not of transformation. The whole canto is being structured to show why slow progress is not enough and why the soul Savitri is seeking is the one that can finish what these three together cannot.

The Promethean echo

The echo here is the most chilling — and most contemporary — passage of the canto. It is the voice of the progressive human ego — the scientific-technological Titan who has succeeded:

"I am the heir of the forces of the earth, Slowly I make good my right to my estate; A growing godhead in her divinised mud, I climb, a claimant to the throne of heaven. The last-born of the earth I stand the first… For me and my use the universe was made. Immortal spirit in the perishing clay, I am God still unevolved in human form; Even if he is not, he becomes in me."

Sri Aurobindo composed Savitri across the decades that produced industrial civilisation; the speech is unmistakably a portrait of that civilisation's self-image. It catalogues actual achievements:

"I have seized her powers and harnessed for my work… I will make glass and raiment out of milk, Make iron velvet, water unbreakable stone… I have used the mystery of the cosmic waves To see far distance and to hear far words; I have conquered Space and knitted close all earth."

And then it turns toward the achievements that frighten Sri Aurobindo most:

"I have found the atoms from which he built the worlds: The first tremendous cosmic energy Missioned shall leap to slay my enemy kin, Expunge a nation or abolish a race, Death's silence leave where there was laughter and joy."

The atom-bomb passage is the canto's reminder that the speech being given is real, and that its endpoint is genuinely terrible. The Titan's ambition closes with an unbounded claim:

"When earth is mastered, I shall conquer heaven; The gods shall be my aides or menial folk, No wish I harbour unfulfilled shall die: Omnipotence and omniscience shall be mine."

This is the force without wisdom that the Madonna of Might tried to channel and could not contain. The pattern is the same as in the first movement: the divine version of a power is necessary; the human distortion is its dark twin. Both speak the same language because they are reaching toward the same object — the second through aspiration, the first through usurpation.

Savitri's answer

Her reply diagnoses the missing piece:

"Madonna of might, Mother of works and force, Thou art a portion of my soul put forth To help mankind and help the travail of Time… But without wisdom power is like a wind, It can breathe upon the heights and kiss the sky, It cannot build the extreme eternal things. Thou hast given men strength, wisdom thou couldst not give."

Without wisdom power is like a wind. The line answers the Titan's speech directly. The conquering ego has acquired vast power and not the wisdom to know what to do with it. The Madonna gave strength but could not give wisdom. The next movement is the Madonna of Wisdom — but, again, in incomplete form.

Third — the Madonna of Light

The path reaches a higher and stranger place — a peace in which the simplest things are intimately divine:

She came into a high and happy space, A wide tower of vision whence all could be seen… There was a carol of birds and murmur of bees, And all that is common and natural and sweet, Yet intimately divine to heart and soul.

The third Madonna sits in this country:

A Woman sat in clear and crystal light: Heaven had unveiled its lustre in her eyes, Her feet were moonbeams, her face was a bright sun, Her smile could persuade a dead lacerated heart To live again and feel the hands of calm.

Her speech places her in the work of awakening rather than suffering or conflict:

"O Savitri, I am thy secret soul. I have come down to the wounded desolate earth To heal her pangs and lull her heart to rest And lay her head upon the Mother's lap That she may dream of God and know his peace…"

She describes herself as the bringer of intuitive light, the patient labour that uses everything:

"I make even sin and error stepping-stones And all experience a long march towards Light. Out of the Inconscient I build consciousness, And lead through death to reach immortal Life."

The line Out of the Inconscient I build consciousness names the cosmic work The Inconscient article gathers in detail — evolution as the Divine remembering itself through matter. The Madonna of Light is that remembering as a feminine power.

She then describes the many faces in which the divine appears to human beings — heroism, sainthood, wisdom, beauty:

"He is the crown of the martyr burned in flame And the glad resignation of the saint And courage indifferent to the wounds of Time And the hero's might wrestling with death and fate… He is Beauty, nectar of the passionate soul, He is the Truth by which the spirit lives… He is Eternity lured from hour to hour, He is infinity in a little space: He is immortality in the arms of death."

These are the highest forms of the human possible in present conditions. She works to lift souls into them. But she names her own limit:

"But human mind clings to its ignorance And to its littleness the human heart And to its right to grief the earthly life. Only when Eternity takes Time by the hand, Only when infinity weds the finite's thought, Can man be free from himself and live with God. I bring meanwhile the gods upon the earth; I bring back hope to the despairing heart… I shall save earth, if earth consents to be saved."

I shall save earth, if earth consents to be saved. The qualifier names the same incompleteness that the first two Madonnas confessed. She has the light to give, but she cannot yet make humanity receive it.

The agnostic echo

The echo from below is the most subtle of the three because it is the voice of the honest rationalist — the scientific mind that has done good work and refuses what it cannot verify. Sri Aurobindo gives it dignity before he gives it diagnosis:

"I am the mind of God's great ignorant world Ascending to knowledge by the steps he made; I am the all-discovering Thought of man. I am a god fettered by Matter and sense…"

The catalogue of its achievements is extensive — astronomy, geology, evolution, biology, genetics. I have classed the changes of her stony crust… The tree of evolution I have sketched… I have detected plasm and cell and gene. What is missing is named with equal honesty:

"If God is at work, his secrets I have found. But still the Cause of things is left in doubt, Their truth flees from pursuit into a void; When all has been explained nothing is known."

And the modern resignation — the agnostic's reasonable refusal:

"Perhaps the world is an error of our sight, A trick repeated in each flash of sense, An unreal mind hallucinates the soul With a stress-vision of false reality, Or a dance of Maya veils the void Unborn."

The voice closes with the refusal of the spiritual quest in its most temperate form:

"Nay, let me work within my mortal bounds, Not live beyond life nor think beyond the mind; Our smallness saves us from the Infinite… Human I am, human let me remain Till in the Inconscient I fall dumb and sleep. A high insanity, a chimaera is this, To think that God lives hidden in the clay And that eternal Truth can dwell in Time, And call to her to save our self and world. How can man grow immortal and divine Transmuting the very stuff of which he is made? This wizard gods may dream, not thinking men."

This wizard gods may dream, not thinking men. The whole sceptical refusal of the spiritual project — Sri Aurobindo's project specifically — in a single sentence. The agnostic is not stupid; he is exactly intelligent enough to know that what he cannot verify, he will not believe, and that what is being asked of him is the suspension of that rule. He will not consent. Our smallness saves us from the Infinite.

Savitri's answer

Her reply names what intuitive light cannot do on its own:

"Madonna of light, Mother of joy and peace, Thou art a portion of my self put forth To raise the spirit to its forgotten heights And wake the soul by touches of the heavens. Because thou art, the soul draws near to God… But not by showering heaven's golden rain Upon the intellect's hard and rocky soil Can the tree of Paradise flower on earthly ground… Even if thou rain down intuition's rays, The mind of man will think it earth's own gleam, His spirit by spiritual ego sink, Or his soul dream shut in sainthood's brilliant cell Where only a bright shadow of God can come."

The diagnosis is the rest of Savitri's case against the standard spiritual options. Showering light on an unprepared mind produces three outcomes: the mind will take the light as its own ("think it earth's own gleam"); the spirit will inflate into spiritual ego; or the soul will end up in sainthood's brilliant cell — a closed mystical life that misses the world rather than transforming it. None of these is the goal. The promise:

"His hunger for the eternal thou must nurse And fill his yearning heart with heaven's fire And bring God down into his body and life. One day I will return, His hand in mine, And thou shalt see the face of the Absolute. Then shall the holy marriage be achieved, Then shall the divine family be born."

Bring God down into his body and life. The standing programme of Sri Aurobindo's yoga is named in passing. The holy marriage — hieros gamos — between the Absolute and earth is the consummation he is aiming at, of which Savitri's marriage to Satyavan is the local and personal sign.

The shape the canto leaves behind

By its end the canto has done two things at once. It has acknowledged the three great soul-forces that work in humanity, and it has passed them. Each is a portion. None is the source. The figure who can send them all out has not yet been found. Canto 5 — The Finding of the Soul — is that finding.

A second thing the canto has done is more subtle: it has placed the three classical paths of spiritual life — devotion (compassion's love), the warrior's path (force in the service of right), and knowledge (the path of light) — and shown each as partial. Sri Aurobindo's integral yoga is structurally the refusal of choosing among these three. The soul behind them all is what each path tries to reach. The yoga is the path to the source rather than to the streams.

Connections

This canto develops, from inside Savitri's own being, the doctrine of The Divine Mother that Aswapati met from outside in The Adoration of the Divine Mother and The Vision and the Boon. The three Madonnas are condensed versions of Mahalakshmi, Mahakali, and Maheshwari / Mahasaraswati from Sri Aurobindo's tract The Mother — though here the schema is simplified to three and the dramatic frame is different: each speaks for herself and is answered by her human echo. The Titan echo of the second Madonna develops further what The Way of Fate and the Problem of Pain called the Adversary — here as the human form of that Adversary, the conquering ego. The agnostic echo of the third extends, from the modern side, the rationalist plain Savitri passed through in The Entry into the Inner Countries. The promise that closes each movement — One day I will return — anticipates the rest of the epic: Books 9–11 are the journey in which the Eternal's cup, the mirror of God, and the face of the Absolute will be brought back to give the three soul-forces what they lack. The next canto, The Finding of the Soul, is the meeting with the source from which all three were sent out.

Open questions

Sources